Book Review: The Wife Upstairs by Freida McFadden

Freida McFadden‘s “The Wife Upstairs” is a thrilling and contemporary retelling of Charlotte Brontë’s classic novel, “Jane Eyre.” With its modern twist, McFadden captivates readers with a gripping tale of love, betrayal, and dark secrets.

Set in the upscale suburb of Thornfield Estates, the story follows Jane, a young woman struggling to make a living as a dog walker and harboring a mysterious past. When she crosses paths with Eddie Rochester, a wealthy widower and Thornfield Estates’ most eligible bachelor, her life takes an unexpected turn.

As Jane enters Eddie’s world, she becomes increasingly entangled in the web of lies and deceit that surround him. Eddie’s late wife, Bea, drowned under mysterious circumstances, leaving Eddie haunted by guilt and secrets. Jane soon discovers that the opulent life she has always desired comes at a price greater than she ever imagined.

McFadden’s writing is sharp and engrossing, effortlessly drawing readers into her dark and atmospheric world. Each chapter is narrated by different characters, providing multiple perspectives to the story and allowing readers to delve deeper into the complex lives of the characters.

One of the book’s strengths lies in its character development. McFadden expertly crafts multi-dimensional characters with flaws, vulnerabilities, and hidden agendas. Jane, in particular, is a compelling protagonist, fiercely independent and determined to rise above her troubled past. Her resilience and wit make her a character readers can root for, even as she makes questionable choices.

The pacing of the novel is another standout element. McFadden skillfully builds the tension, gradually unraveling the mysteries surrounding Eddie, Bea, and Thornfield Estates. The plot twists are both unexpected and satisfying, keeping readers on the edge of their seats throughout the book.

While “The Wife Upstairs” pays homage to Brontë’s original novel, it successfully stands on its own as a contemporary thriller. McFadden brings the story into the present day, addressing themes such as social media obsession, class disparities, and the consequences of one’s past catching up with them. These modern elements add depth to the narrative and make it relevant to today’s readers.

However, some readers may find the plot to be predictable, especially if they are familiar with the original “Jane Eyre.” Additionally, the ending, although satisfying, may leave some wanting more closure.

Overall, “The Wife Upstairs” is a gripping and entertaining read that combines elements of suspense, romance, and psychological intrigue. Freida McFadden’s skillful writing and clever reimagining of a beloved classic make this book a must-read for fans of contemporary thrillers and Brontë enthusiasts alike.